Skip to content

The exemplar

Some years ago, while walking down a hallway in a well-known and highly regarded organization that I was visiting, I unexpectedly observed this scene: Some way ahead of me was a junior manager, looking authoritative and in control of events. It seemed to me that it was such as these, so imbued with confidence and competence, who produced the international respect in which this outfit was held. How did they create them?

A new employee approached from the opposite direction. Like all of his cadre of recruits to the firm, he was quietly but irrepressibly smiling with anticipation about his day, his future in this exciting, dynamic company. I saw the back of the manager’s head turn as he crisply spoke the young man’s name. I could clearly see the latter’s face look over, eager to learn, to be of some service, excited to have been singled out.

But the manager only spit out something staggeringly stupid, personal, pointless, and gratuitously demeaning. Then he turned his head forward again, and strode on without having missed a step, proud of himself for the lightning-sharp display of unanswerable power.

It looked to me as though the impact of his wholly unanticipated words nearly stopped the young employee momentarily in his tracks. And I’ll never forget his face, the flicker of emotions; shock, confusion, disappointment, helplessness. By the time we passed each other, his head was lowered, and his expression had resolved into bitterness and anger.

Seems like an odd thing to recall so intensely, doesn’t it? Certainly, it was almost instantly forgotten by the manager who provoked it. But I’ll warrant the employee never forgot; I sure didn’t, and I was just an observer.

Possibly the most forcefully striking thing about this incident was its aberrant occurrence in an outfit the young initiates of which had joined largely due to its reputation for having the highest possible standards in this area. And fortunately, it was indeed far from characteristic of the practice of leadership in the organization. Nor, moreover, is it of the military, governmental, or civilian organizations I have known. And, surely, neither is it of those that you are familiar with.

Nevertheless, it is likely that each of you reading this recalls something very much like it meted out by a nominal senior to yourself or a colleague early in your careers. Even now, look around you and note the bad-attitude employees you may see, the nervously skeptical atmosphere that seems to pervade some organizations or teams, or the peculiarly eager turnover.

Or, consider your management peers with the classically caustic “they’re going to have it as tough as I did” approach. You may have noticed others who seem to think that it is perfectly normal to give instant and thoughtless expression of their personal aggravations through their positions of seniority or authority upon their hapless juniors.

You can see, of course, the very gloom they spread, the tremendous energy required to counter their poisonous influence on an organization. But there they are.

Where do you suppose they come from?

Today’s tip: One of the chief proponents of the modern leadership movement, Marshall Goldsmith, recently addressed today’s general topic in his BusinessWeek column. While clothed in the standard leadership atmosphere and jargon, the case is made effectively and forcefully, and the lesson offered is right on target.

Have you noticed the blue “Sphere” icon, below? When you click on it, it will produce a window offering you content related to today’s item from other blogs and the regular media. Give it a try!

And, while you’re clicking around down there, don’t forget to subscribe, by email or RSS reader!

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Sphere: Related Content

4 Comments

  1. Jim,

    That’s one heck of a good closing question. And I’ve been trying to figure out a sensible answer. But I can’t.

    The kind of individuals described are the kind that, I think, most of us avoid at all costs. How they get connected, promoted, and “tenured” would be a fascinating study for someone willing to undertake it.

    In the meantime, their toxic presence will continue to cause everything from stress to turnover to actual disease. . .

    Tuesday, March 25, 2008 at 5:42 am | Permalink
  2. Jim Stroup wrote:

    Hi Steve,

    I once was in a discussion with some senior managers who were complaining about another senior manager who worked for one of them. One of them said that when you see a poor manager like that, ask yourself how management development efforts are. If you are too timid to critique and correct your juniors, ultimately you have no choice but to praise them in your evaluations. If you do that, how can you not expect them to be promoted when the time comes (especially when, as in this organization, promotion is handled by a committee at HQ)?

    That’s part of the problem, but I think another is that we raise people with this attitude by displaying it ourselves. Young adults entering the work force may be adults, but they are still young, and even a transient encounter like the one described in the post can have a profound effect on the path the rest of their career takes.

    Does that make sense to you?

    Tuesday, March 25, 2008 at 9:57 am | Permalink
  3. Wally Bock wrote:

    Excellent post, Jim. Where do they come from? I bow to the wisdom of Pogo. “We have met the enemy and he is us.”

    Hopefully he, or she, is us on a bad day, but “us” it is. Sometimes the nastiness and stupidity comes from people who only have a little bit of power in their world and mean to use it. Sometimes it comes from people with a lot of power who have had their behind kissed for years and are out of touch with the havoc they can wreak with the smallest comment.

    I know that I look back on some of the awful things I did when I was younger and I can’t help wondering what new idiocy I’m practicing today, but unaware of.

    One serious aspect of this issue is that it only takes one mean or nasty or thoughtless comment to affect the behavior of the person you’ve just ripped. As Mark Twain said, “A cat that sits on a hot stove will never sit on a hot stove again. But he won’t sit on a cold stove, either.”

    Wednesday, March 26, 2008 at 10:34 pm | Permalink
  4. Jim Stroup wrote:

    Hello Wally,

    That’s the thing, isn’t it? - Us on a bad day or lousy influences we tolerate.

    We leave trails of impressions behind us the consequences of which we should not underestimate.

    I never thought of that Twain quote in this context - excellent!

    Thanks for stopping by with this.

    Thursday, March 27, 2008 at 10:29 am | Permalink

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *
*
*