The commonly offered functions for leadership often seem to merely serve as glib introductions to the particular corner of the niche-riddled leadership market that any particular guru wishes to draw us in to. But underneath all the smoke generated by the leadership industry, there has to be some spark; there has to be some real purpose that leadership serves.
To begin with, let’s consider the possibility that the only real need that the notion of individual leadership serves is the bottomless insecurity, combined with the juvenile but eternal aspiration to heroism, that so many of us seem to secretly nourish. Add to all of this the mysteriously seductive master-of-the-universe aura of power associated with leadership of global enterprises, and you’ve got yourself a major trap.
Let’s not dismiss this lightly – it is a strong instinct that creates a powerful demand. We all know that we make decisions on emotion and then rationalize them, after a fashion, on logic. Suppliers know that, too – including gurus, authors, and consultants. And it serves as a suitable explanation for the strong draw we feel to the nonsensical justifications for the wares pushed on us by the modern leadership movement, some of which we reviewed yesterday.
So, is that all? Or is there a real function, a real purpose uniquely served by something called “leadership” beneath all this self-delusional self-absorption?
In the next two days, we’ll take a closer look at both sides of this question, as presented today. Tomorrow’s will be in the form of a book review. Thursday, I’ll tell a story that I think points to the function leadership really may serve - and that may suggest how it really works. Please do join in!
—
Today’s tip: Speaking of trying to figure out what leadership is and who needs it, consider this review of the topic from the perspective of women managers, by Dan McCarthy at Great Leadership.
—
Want to read articles from the Encyclopedia Britannica for free? Take a moment to scroll down the sidebar on the main site a bit: right below my current readings you will see a dynamically renewing box pointing to articles on capitalism from the Britannica. These are typically available only by paid subscription, but if you click through to an article from here, you will be able to read it for free. Try it!
And speaking of subscriptions, ours here are always free! Why not subscribe by email or RSS reader now?
Technorati Tags: leadership, niche, market, guru, purpose, insecurity, heroism, power, demand, decision, emotion, rationalize, logic, consultant, justification, function, women, manager, Dan McCarthy, Great Leadership
Sphere: Related Content













2 Comments
I enjoyed both yesterday’s and today’s post on leadership. I think that the modern definition of leadership should take behavioral aspects into consideration.
I am specifically reminiscing about an article that I read last week on CFA Magazine (link below). Let me know what you think.
http://www.cfapubs.org/doi/abs/10.2469/cfm.v19.n3.9
Best and keep on posting.
Hello Jon,
Thank you for your visit and your kind comments. Unfortunately, I am not currently a subscriber to CFA Magazine, and a subscription is required to view the linked article, but I will try to learn more about the interesting idea that is its foundation, as well as the about the perspectives of the author.
Thanks again!
Post a Comment